Customer Reviews
Overall rating: 4.9 / 5 from 1948 reviews.
He’s a Christmas present for my grandson. I think this little piece of cheese is going to get a lot of love
Sandralena G.
5/5
Verified
November 20, 2026
Forgotten Moldy Parmesan Cheese
impeccable. exquisite even. so cute
Patricia R.
5/5
Verified
November 19, 2026
Forgotten Banana Peel
perfect! my partner loves it
Patricia R.
5/5
Verified
November 19, 2026
Forgotten Burnt Toast
Love it! Gifting it to my friend and the cherries are better than I could have hoped! Looking forward to seeing how others like them.
Emma F.
5/5
Verified
November 19, 2026
Forgotten Cherries
I saw it on Instagram and knew I had to have it :( He's so cute, I wanted to give him a home <3
Sarah K.
5/5
Verified
November 19, 2026
Forgotten Burnt Toast
Great product, received very quickly.
Shane W.
5/5
Verified
November 19, 2026
Free Mystery Forgotten Month Sticker
i love it
Letícia G.
5/5
Verified
November 19, 2026
Forgotten Moldy Parmesan Cheese
I love these plushies! They are just the cutest, softest, and sad little guys, you HAVE to rescue them!!
Dawn C.
5/5
Verified
November 19, 2026
Forgotten Burnt Toast
It’s very cute, soft, and as advertised, but it’s smaller than expected as I was expecting a full plushie and got a keychain type thing
Ellie V.
4/5
Verified
November 19, 2026
Forgotten Burnt Toast
Nothing like some burnt December toast in these trying times to warm the heart <3 thanks for the free sticker it’s really cool
Cameron C.
5/5
Verified
November 19, 2026
Free Mystery Forgotten Month Sticker
Got him along with the blueberry so they could be friends and I love everything about them they are soft and perfect <3
Cameron C.
5/5
Verified
November 19, 2026
Forgotten Jack O' Lantern
I love my Forgotten Jack O' Lantern! I put him in my car with my Tee Turtles so he'll never be forgotten again. 🥹
Caitlyn Z.
5/5
Verified
November 19, 2026
Forgotten Jack O' Lantern
It’s very high quality and the experience was great and I like the packaging. Also it smells nice 😳
Grayson Z.
5/5
November 18, 2026
Forgotten Single Blueberry
He’s very nice. I wish i could make him smile </3. I accidentally threw the sticker that came with it away so check the folded up receipt in your order!
Mira M.
5/5
Verified
November 18, 2026
Forgotten Moldy Parmesan Cheese
Super cute little freebie, I got the pair of cherries:)
Hannah F.
5/5
Verified
November 18, 2026
Free Mystery Forgotten Month Sticker
he is my son now.
Ireland H.
5/5
Verified
November 18, 2026
Forgotten Burnt Toast
HE'S SO CUTE I LOVE HIM OMG
Skylynn D.
5/5
Verified
November 18, 2026
Forgotten Jack O' Lantern
I wanted the cheese so cute
Mary D.
5/5
Verified
November 18, 2026
Free Mystery Forgotten Month Sticker
This is a present for Xmas and he’s literally perfect
Mary D.
5/5
Verified
November 18, 2026
Forgotten Peter the Opossum
I love these sm I’m buying more
Mary D.
5/5
Verified
November 18, 2026
Forgotten Burnt Toast
This is Toast Malone and I love him.
Texas M.
5/5
Verified
November 18, 2026
Forgotten Burnt Toast
I love this guy so much and will cherish them forever
Jayden B.
5/5
Verified
November 17, 2026
Forgotten Banana Peel
So cute
Tiffany N.
5/5
Verified
November 17, 2026
Forgotten Single Blueberry
Love it
Tiffany N.
5/5
Verified
November 17, 2026
Forgotten Birthday Cake
They're genuinely my babies I love them sm ☹️
Cassie W.
5/5
Verified
November 16, 2026
Forgotten Bitten Apple
I spend my night cooing to them like some parent to make that sad face go away and also for me to able to sleep. I'd do a lot of things to make it happy even if it's sad face won't change..
Raven E.
5/5
Verified
November 16, 2026
Forgotten Moldy Parmesan Cheese
He is the cutest little guy ever, i hung him off my keys and i nearly cry every time i see him
Nell H.
5/5
Verified
November 16, 2026
Forgotten Burnt Toast
like it's okay, we all fall victim to it 🥹
Nas L.
5/5
Verified
November 14, 2026
Forgotten Burnt Toast
This little burnt toast brings me so much joy every day! Who knew I could commiserate so well with a piece of bread? He's even cuter and softer than I anticipated, and he arrived surprisingly quickly!
Hannah Elisa V.
5/5
Verified
November 14, 2026
Forgotten Burnt Toast
My daughter is obsessed! She wants them all now!
Jaime O.
5/5
Verified
November 14, 2026
Forgotten Single Blueberry
I refuse to let this marvelous little blueberry go forgotten. He WILL be loved and he WILL be remembered as will his Jack-o-lantern buddy! They are friends and they rule. They are perfect and soft and I couldn’t be happier with them. 10/10 experience, will probably be guilted into buying more sad fruit
Cameron C.
5/5
Verified
November 12, 2026
Forgotten Single Blueberry
I love him sm
Zoe W.
5/5
Verified
November 12, 2026
Forgotten Burnt Toast
he’s literally so cute
Emi H.
5/5
November 12, 2026
Forgotten Burnt Toast
They’re the absolute cutest!!
Madi N.
5/5
Verified
November 12, 2026
Forgotten Moldy Parmesan Cheese
SO FREAKING CUUUUTE! got the burnt toast for my mom who eats it burnt religiously. PRECIOUS!!
Augi A.
5/5
Verified
November 12, 2026
Forgotten Burnt Toast
my cousin asked me for it for his birthday this month. it’s the only thing he asked me for and he absolutely loves it!!
Leah S.
5/5
Verified
November 12, 2026
Forgotten Single Blueberry
My wife loves our new family member however our son is displeased to be in the presence of such a cute plushy
Maxon T.
5/5
Verified
November 11, 2026
Forgotten Burnt Toast
Produkt kann immer noch nicht ab, sollte letzte Woche da sein
Max S.
1/5
Verified
November 11, 2026
Free Mystery Forgotten Month Sticker
Produkt kam immer noch nicht an, sollte letzte Woche da sein
Max S.
1/5
Verified
November 11, 2026
Forgotten Burnt Toast
Genuinely the best thing ever
Maxwell I.
5/5
Verified
November 11, 2026
Forgotten Bitten Apple