10/10 sad toast would recommend
The Lost Two (2 Mystery Plushies)
The Lost Two (2 Mystery Plushies)
Regular price
$24.00
Regular price
$0.00
Sale price
$24.00
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Quantity
Couldn't load pickup availability
Nobody had chosen them yet, so they stayed close together while they waited 🥺.
Each day, they sit quietly side by side hoping that someone kind might finally choose them and bring them home together.
Each pair includes 2 hand-picked mystery plushies chosen from our collection of forgotten friends 🧺.
• No repeated companions within the same fellowship
• Leave a small note at checkout describing your vibe and any fruit or vegi allergies, and we shall do our best to gather companions suited for your journey
✨ Includes beaded keychain for everyday carry
📏 Size: Length 4" x Depth 4" x Height 4"
🪡 Always handmade with love & care
🧸 Crafted from soft high-quality vegan fabric
☁️ Filled with premium mildew resistant stuffing
❤️ Perfect snuggle, travel, desk & everything buddy
Customer Reviews
Overall rating: 4.9 / 5 from 1634 reviews.
It's adorable
He’s so adorable I added him onto my backpack so he can come everywhere with me!
Love it!
These little guys were the perfect addition to my stuffie family, they’re the cutest!
Cute!
Loved!
omggg these are absolutely so cute!! really nice quality and arrived quickly :)
I love him so much!
I love him! He’s such a cute lil stinker.
Love my little guy so much!
love him 🍞
Ahh, I love it it's so cute! Minus just 1 star though because the chain broke after hooking and unhooking it maybe like 3 times? And also I think the face is a weee too dark but still super cute
Burnt toast is super cute!
Its adorable and amazing quality, cant wait to add him to my Keychain collection and show the world hes isnt so forgotten anymore.
Blueberry was a birthday gift for my friend and she absolutely loves him! He is immediately part of her keys and will no longer be forgotten <3
I absolutely loved my burnt toast and there was a delay in shipping BUT that was on my end, I accidentally put a wrong number in my address and staff were available to email and helped me fix the situation so now I can enjoy my plushie💙
It is great
My wife absolutely love it and has him on her work bag, never to be forgotten again.
Amazing, arrived fast, didn’t get damaged. Girlfriend loves it so I love it as well 🙂↕️
Very soft and fits right in the palm of your hand 🫐
They are so cute!!! I asked for the pickle and they were so kind to provide <3 will be shopping again!!
Super cute! But if you’re ordering from Germany it’s gonna be very expensive:( I had to pay 18,95€ for shipping, and an extra of 20,14€ of customs fees making it a total of 55,04€ (plus the 15,95€) for a keychain. I still like it though but it’s a bit expensive for people that live in Germany.
love it!
love it!
The cutest purchase i’ve ever made. They’re such good quality & such an amazing product.
love it, so cute and soft!!
I love them so much!:) there super cutie & also super soft i got a pumpkin as well !!<3
I love my burnt toast it’s so cute and soft
Took my blueb to the blueberry festival
My little burnt toast is so adorable, its face is so sad but cute. I can’t wait to put it on my bag!
Forgotten Burnt Toast (SOLD OUT - Preorder for end of July delivery)
I LOVE my little moldy cheese so much. It is adorable, super soft, and I can’t wait to put it on my bag!
I'm so happy I found this little fella. 🥺💛 I absolutely love 'em! ❤️
I got the forgotten blueberry 🥹 he's my son
SO CUTE! I bought him for a friends birthday gift. I cannot wait to give the little guy to her. He is the perfect size for a comfort buddy that you can bring with you everywhere. And so soft!
They are so soft and cute 😍
Exactly as expected
Its so cute i love it so much!
so cute!
This is adorable. I feel so maternal towards it! Fast shipping too!
Customer Reviews
Overall rating: 4.8 / 5 from 24 reviews.
They are so cute!!! I asked for the pickle and they were so kind to provide <3 will be shopping again!!
Everything was SO cute!! I loved it! 10/10 would recommend to a friend :) the sticker was great material and I gave it to a friend who loved it!
so so cute
I received the Forgotten Half Peeled Orange and his bestie, the Forgotten Bitten Pickle and I love them both so much!!!
they're so cute! they aren't forgotten anymore!
Soooooo cutee
these little dudes are just to die for. i got the mystery because i just knew i would be happy with any of them, but i got the ones i wanted the most! i will forever cherish my moldy cheese and bitten apple 🥰
I really love both of them, and shipping was really fast! I put my lil apple on my purse and I gave the banana peel to my lil brother for his 8th grade graduation
They are soooo cute! I love the shark but the apple gets to live on my bag i love them
I like this deal, but unfortunately, I ordered this twice in a row (liked the group I got the first order so much that I got another pair next time I ordered!) and unfortunately got the exact same apple/shark duo in the next batch. I knew it was a risk to get dupes, but I had hoped at least one would be different so I could keep one and gift one. Both ended up being gifted, so it wasn't a total disappointment, but it wasn't super fun for me to open. Oh well. I guess I will just buy the ones I want in the future.
I got an apple and a hammerhead shark, ehich are very cute and an interesting combo! Love the different textures on both of them! Would have loved to have had a keychain on the shark as he is small and I like to connect similar keychains together!
The idea of a mystery pair is fun and all, but all reviews I've seen have been a pairing of the apple and hammerhead shark. That's not a mystery anymore, that just seems lazy. I also got the apple and shark and it kind of lost it's appeal when I know other people got the same pair. The mystery part doesn't seem as genuine anymore.
Very cute. Got the hammerhead and the apple. Hammerhead was claimed by my partner, so I gave the apple a home with the other little friends on my desk.
Ah they were both so cute! I went woth the random mix and ended up with the adorable forgotten apple and thr hammer head shark, which i gave to my friend. While a little small its honestly such good quality and we're both really happy with it!
I saw an ad for these randomly pop up on Threads and knew I had to buy some! The mystery pack was so perfect because my daughter fell in love with them as much as I did! The plushies are so cute and the quality seems like they’ll hold up to being on a middle school backpack!
This was a cute surprise. I’m so happy I got the apple and I gave the hammerhead shark to my hubby. Will definitely be ordering again
So adorable:)
I love these lil guys!! Very cute and good quality, will definitely be hanging them on my bag :)
I love my apple plushie! It's just too cute. I got the shark with my mystery box. I didn't want that one as much, but they're both really cute and small.
Such a fast delivery and such cute plushes with the plushiest of fabric such cute little buddies.
Im always surprised by this pack I’ve gotten and love all the plushies I’ve gotten and will probably buy more but sad my last two packs were exactly the same having forgotten bitten apple and mac the hammerhead shark. But at least my boyfriend and i can have matching plushies so its not all bad getting duplicates.
Super cute plushies! I got the ones I liked. Soft and good quality.
This was really funny too because it was me and my best friends animals. So it was very cute and heartwarming
Silly little dudes :)
