i love it
Forgotten Jack O' Lantern
Forgotten Jack O' Lantern
Couldn't load pickup availability
Meet our very special Forgotten Jack-o'-lantern. He’s been left out way too long, a lil bashed in the head but still holding on 🥺🧡. Once the life of the porch party, now he’s just… there. Sad. Squished. Still kinda cute tho 👻.
This plush is part of our Forgotten Series, a collection of everyday objects that were used, loved... and then quietly left behind.
✨ Includes beaded keychain for everyday carry
📏 Size: Length 4.5" x Depth 5" x Height 4.5"
🪡 Always handmade with love & care
🧸 Crafted from soft high-quality vegan fabric
☁️ Filled with premium mildew resistant stuffing
❤️ Perfect snuggle, travel, desk & everything buddy
Share

Customer Reviews
Overall rating: 4.9 / 5 from 1942 reviews.
I love these plushies! They are just the cutest, softest, and sad little guys, you HAVE to rescue them!!
Dawn C. 5/5 Verified
It’s very cute, soft, and as advertised, but it’s smaller than expected as I was expecting a full plushie and got a keychain type thing
Ellie V. 4/5 Verified
Nothing like some burnt December toast in these trying times to warm the heart <3 thanks for the free sticker it’s really cool
Cameron C. 5/5 Verified
Got him along with the blueberry so they could be friends and I love everything about them they are soft and perfect <3
Cameron C. 5/5 Verified
I love my Forgotten Jack O' Lantern! I put him in my car with my Tee Turtles so he'll never be forgotten again. 🥹
Caitlyn Z. 5/5 Verified
It’s very high quality and the experience was great and I like the packaging. Also it smells nice 😳
Grayson Z. 5/5
He’s very nice. I wish i could make him smile </3. I accidentally threw the sticker that came with it away so check the folded up receipt in your order!
Mira M. 5/5 Verified
Super cute little freebie, I got the pair of cherries:)
Hannah F. 5/5 Verified
he is my son now.
Ireland H. 5/5 Verified
HE'S SO CUTE I LOVE HIM OMG
Skylynn D. 5/5 Verified
I wanted the cheese so cute
Mary D. 5/5 Verified
This is a present for Xmas and he’s literally perfect
Mary D. 5/5 Verified
I love these sm I’m buying more
Mary D. 5/5 Verified
This is Toast Malone and I love him.
Texas M. 5/5 Verified
I love this guy so much and will cherish them forever
Jayden B. 5/5 Verified
So cute
Tiffany N. 5/5 Verified
Love it
Tiffany N. 5/5 Verified
They're genuinely my babies I love them sm ☹️
Cassie W. 5/5 Verified
I spend my night cooing to them like some parent to make that sad face go away and also for me to able to sleep. I'd do a lot of things to make it happy even if it's sad face won't change..
Raven E. 5/5 Verified
He is the cutest little guy ever, i hung him off my keys and i nearly cry every time i see him
Nell H. 5/5 Verified
like it's okay, we all fall victim to it 🥹
Nas L. 5/5 Verified
This little burnt toast brings me so much joy every day! Who knew I could commiserate so well with a piece of bread? He's even cuter and softer than I anticipated, and he arrived surprisingly quickly!
Hannah Elisa V. 5/5 Verified
My daughter is obsessed! She wants them all now!
Jaime O. 5/5 Verified
I refuse to let this marvelous little blueberry go forgotten. He WILL be loved and he WILL be remembered as will his Jack-o-lantern buddy! They are friends and they rule. They are perfect and soft and I couldn’t be happier with them. 10/10 experience, will probably be guilted into buying more sad fruit
Cameron C. 5/5 Verified
I love him sm
Zoe W. 5/5 Verified
he’s literally so cute
Emi H. 5/5
They’re the absolute cutest!!
Madi N. 5/5 Verified
SO FREAKING CUUUUTE! got the burnt toast for my mom who eats it burnt religiously. PRECIOUS!!
Augi A. 5/5 Verified
my cousin asked me for it for his birthday this month. it’s the only thing he asked me for and he absolutely loves it!!
Leah S. 5/5 Verified
My wife loves our new family member however our son is displeased to be in the presence of such a cute plushy
Maxon T. 5/5 Verified
Produkt kann immer noch nicht ab, sollte letzte Woche da sein
Max S. 1/5 Verified
Produkt kam immer noch nicht an, sollte letzte Woche da sein
Max S. 1/5 Verified
Genuinely the best thing ever
Maxwell I. 5/5 Verified
Came faster than I expected!!
Diane H. 5/5 Verified
Love my new little toast, he's super soft and fits perfectly on my bag<3
Hannah F. 5/5 Verified
Super cute and soft and I love the branding and stories connected to each character!
Evelyn D. 5/5 Verified
What a cute design! I love the fact that you can pose the banana peels too, lol.
Christina Y. 5/5 Verified
So cute and well made!!! There is definitely quality in the design and the derpiness makes me smile. xD
Christina Y. 5/5 Verified
Got it for my friends birthday and she loved it
Luca L. 5/5 Verified
Customer Reviews
Overall rating: 4.8 / 5 from 38 reviews.
Got him along with the blueberry so they could be friends and I love everything about them they are soft and perfect <3
Cameron C. 5/5 Verified
I love my Forgotten Jack O' Lantern! I put him in my car with my Tee Turtles so he'll never be forgotten again. 🥹
Caitlyn Z. 5/5 Verified
HE'S SO CUTE I LOVE HIM OMG
Skylynn D. 5/5 Verified
So cute and great quality
Kyleigh T. 5/5 Verified
Perfect item!
A A. 5/5 Verified
seen an ad on tiktok and immediately placed an order pt. 2. shipping was fast and arrived as described. my pumpkin is no longer forgotten. i do like the little details that went into him, the mouth design in particular. i will say pumpkin is bigger than my apple. not inna bad way though, he is just more round (fills out the center of my palm). quality seems well made! would order again!
Zhandell S. 5/5 Verified
jackin myt lil lantern I lvoe him
Andrew G. 5/5 Verified
Loved!
Reagan V. 5/5 Verified
He's so cute! I love how he has a little broken patch! Very nice detail there. He looks amazing on my backpack.
Zander S. 5/5 Verified
He's absolutely stunning! I love how he has a little broken patch! I like that detail a lot. He looks great on my backpack.
Zander 5/5
Adopt this little guy!!! You wont regret it! Well made, soft and great size!!❤️
Terri J. 5/5 Verified
Had to get 2!!! So adoreable!! Love!!❤️
Terri J. 5/5 Verified
These are honestly some of the cutest plushies ever! I really love them and hope to make the best home for more soon.
Solena M. 5/5 Verified
He is an adorable pumpkin . 🎃
Maria S. 5/5 Verified
the cutest little guy
Angela K. 5/5 Verified
He’s my son.
Bailee S. 5/5 Verified
Forgotten Jack O' Lantern (SOLD OUT - Preorder for end of June)
It is so cute!
Shelley C. 5/5 Verified
Forgotten Jack O' Lantern (SOLD OUT - Preorder for mid June)
Let me start off that the plush is so cute and I love it!!! I will absolutely be purchasing more! Some feedback: I wish it was rounder, like in the picture. It’s more flat, which is fine, but it makes the face of the pumpkin hard to see when it’s hanging. Also, the tag is in a weird place. If I wanted to take a picture of the plush the large white tag is basically front and center making it a little awkward.
Madison H. 4/5 Verified
Love it so much! But I'm scared to lose it if I put it on my bag-where it's attached to the chain is dainty.
Diana M. 5/5 Verified
Forgotten Jack O' Lantern (SOLD OUT - Preorder for end of June)
You could reply to my messages that I sent you telling that you sent my order to the wrong address. My shipping address is in TN. Your delivery was to ME. I have replied to your "how do you like your plushies" saying I didn't get them but I get no reply from your company. Please check my order and see what went wrong.
Kelly L. 1/5 Verified
The little rotten Jack is perfect! He never has to feel overlooked again! We love just the way he is.
Connie H. 5/5 Verified
It’s so soft and cute!
Taeyong L. 5/5 Verified
Its very small
Austin E. 3/5 Verified
Also adorable!
Alex B. 5/5 Verified
It was very well made
Flavio G. 5/5 Verified
So cute. He hangs from my everyday bag. Love him so much
Yoclyn V. 5/5
My wife loved these! She mentioned she saw them so I surprised her. Easy win my dudes reading this.
Matthew T. 5/5 Verified
So soft.
Júlia S. 5/5 Verified
I ordered the forgotten jack o lantern plush & I love him so much! He’s too cute & so soft 🎃
Shelby S. 5/5 Verified
very good bit slow on delivery
Christina M. 5/5 Verified
bought this for myself as a spooky szn girly and it’s the cutest pumpkin ever 🥹
Kelly P. 5/5 Verified
So soft and well made! The little guy is absolutely adorable. I love him.
Marie O. 5/5 Verified
i love him so much 😭🎃
Ri T. 5/5
I bought my plushies as stocking stuffers for my friends and my boyfriend and I’m SO EXCITED to give it to them because they’re so cute!! Also wanted to support a smaller business this holiday season and they came SO fast and I’m really happy with everything overall!
Melanie A. 5/5 Verified
the cutest baby
Aimée L. 5/5 Verified
Icabob is so cute. Look at his little FACE!
Shondolyn G. 5/5 Verified
This little pumpkin might be a little bruised but is still so cute.
Keith W. 5/5 Verified
feels really well made, he’s kinda too chunky to be a keychain but that’s still an option!
Sarah L. 5/5 Verified